Asphalt shingles cost less, but they need to get replaced early, whereas metal roofing costs more but can surely last longer. However, the roofing you choose depends on your budget, your plan to stay, and your roof’s shape.
Metal Roof Cost in North York vs Asphalt Shingle Roof Cost in North York
Asphalt shingle roof cost in North York is about $4.50–$9.00/sq ft depending on the grade of shingle. Three-tab shingles are around $4.50–$6.00/sq ft, and architectural or dimensional shingles cost $6.00–$9.00/sq ft.
Metal roof cost in North York is commonly $9.00–$26.00/sq ft. Corrugated panels are near $9–$13/sq ft, while standing seam systems are for $13–$26/sq ft.
The cost for asphalt shingles is around $8,500–$18,000 and for metal it is $18,000–$40,000 or more in North York depending on size and the material you choose.
Metal Roof Lifespan vs Asphalt Shingle Lifespan
Asphalt shingle lifespan in GTA is 15–25 years for architectural shingles and the lifespan of three tab shingles is 15–18 years.
Lifespan of metal roof is commonly 40–70 years. Standing seam steel works for 50–70 years and metal shingles or panels work for around 40–60 years
Long Term Cost of Metal Roofing vs Asphalt
The cost of metal roofing is lower than asphalt shingles in long term if your plan is to stay in the home for many years. In 40–50 years, you pay for two or three roofs made of asphalt shingles whereas only one metal roofing is required in this time frame.
Asphalt Shingles: lower in price but needs to be replaced in 20-25 years.
Metal: higher price, but one roof can work for 40–70 years.
Durability and Weather
In North York there is heavy snow, ice, freeze and thaw cycles, strong winds, and summer heat. So each material behaves in a different way:
Metal roof durability: Metal can take snow load easily and it can shed snow properly, which prevents formation of ice dams. Metal doesn’t absorb water, so ice dams rarely form. Metal roofs can handle very high wind speeds and can sustain in different weather conditions.
Asphalt shingle durability: Architectural shingles perform nicely but get damaged from UV rays, freeze thaw cycles, and moisture. Granule loss, curling, and cracks in shingles happen with time.
Weather resistance in metal roof is good for snow and wind, while asphalt shingles weather resistance is fine for most seasons but gets damaged because of repeated freeze thaw cycles and UV exposure.
Metal Roofing Maintenance vs Asphalt Shingle Maintenance
For metal roofing, You need inspections in spring and fall, clear debris from valleys, and check sealants on penetrations. Standing seam systems need less work than fastener panels.
For asphalt shingles, you need regular inspections for missing shingles, granule loss, moss, and flashing issues. With time, repairs become more common.
Energy Efficiency and Comfort
Metal roofs reflect more solar heat that is why it reduces 10-25% cooling cost in comparison to asphalt. It also depends on colour and coating. Asphalt shingles absorb more heat. In winter, proper attic insulation and ventilation is important to prevent ice dams for both roofs.
Appearance and Design Flexibility
Asphalt has many colours, profiles, and styles that give rich looks at a low price.
Metal comes in standing seam panels, metal shingles, and stone coated steel and colour and finish choices are present. Many homeowners like the modern lines of standing seam.
Installation and Repair Considerations
Installation: For metal roofing, roofers who have experience with thermal movement, fastener patterns, and flashings are recommended. Whereas asphalt is less complex.
Repairs: Asphalt repairs do not require much money. Metal repairs do not happen very frequently but can be very expensive.
When Each Option Makes Sense
If you have limited budget and plan to sell your house within 10–15 years, you should choose asphalt shingles.
If you plan to stay for more than 20 years, and you want maximum roof durability and good weather performance, you should choose metal.
Factors You Should Consider Before Choosing a Roof
- Budget
- Years you want to stay in the house
- Roof slope and complexity of the roof.
- Local climate like shade, trees, and wind.
- Your contractors’ experience with the material you have chosen.
